miund.com

Flirting With The Non Believer

08.20.2008 · Posted in Curhat, Mikir, Thoughts In English

I’ve set up a personal rule that all English posts should be posted here rather than in this blog. But I have a ‘Thoughts In English’ category here, so I figured ‘why not’. It’s just so hard to write so eloquently about this matter in my mother tongue, but I don’t really know why I want to post it here.
So the deal is, after my declaration of my newfound love for non-fiction books on I’ve been reading ‘God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything’ by Christopher Hitchens. The book consists of many stuff and references that only scholars know (read: I know shite about these stuff, I bought the book merely because the title is so provocative and the fact that the cover is yellow. Don’t ask further, I have a thing for yellow books). I’m just up to the third chapter, where the author talks about how most religions (including mine, surprisingly) despises pigs, swine, bacon whatever.

The strange (and slightly) scary thing is, so far the stuff this guy talks about, makes sense to me. I don’t consider myself a religious person, but I do believe in God and to me, anything regarding to faith is not to be questioned by anyone.

And now I am so freaking tempted to put the book inside a freezer like Joey from Friends did when he read ‘Little Women’. It’s strange how I want so much to keep on reading, but wanting so much to stop at the same time. I’ve alternated my reading material with Woody Allen’s Side Effects, recently given to me by a good friend. The humor doesn’t seem to kick in enough to shake my preoccupations away.

It is really like standing on the edge of a cliff, looking down, knowing that jumping is stupid but you can’t stop wondering as you swim inside some survivor’s head. This is the thing I don’t like about reading serious stuff (albeit the ‘entertaining’ crap they put on the reviews on the back cover). I am forced to enter the realms of some stranger’s thoughts and it’s not always pleasant. It’s better to swim in a trashy mind, like I did with Eat Pray Love. This guy’s mind… is new untouched grounds for me, yet totally unapologetic.

Some say ‘don’t play with fire’, but some other say ‘live on the edge’. I think I am the latter. With an invisible harness called faith.

I told my friend Mr. J, that I am reading this book, and he said:

“There is absolutely a God, and He is indeed great. The thing is we don’t need anybody telling us HOW to worship Him.”

That’s pretty much what I have in mind for the last 29 years.

Maybe the giddiness I got from reading the book is caused by exactly this. In the midst of my not wanting to be told how to worship, I came across a book telling me bluntly that no worshiping is necessary at all. And it makes me somewhat angry, but I don’t realize that I was angry, and it’s all manifested in a series of confusion.

I am not hating the book like I hated Eat Pray Love. I read the disclaimer before starting to read it, made my peace with it and haven’t finished it yet. All I am saying is, it’s hard to agree nor disagree. The only thing I regret is not sticking by the humor genre. I am so not made for these kind of books. There’s no point flirting with it when I already choose never to act on it anyway.

But again, strangely, the more I say it, the more I delve into it. I guess it’s human nature to play with fire.

Oh well, to avoid getting burned, I’m putting the book in the freezer.

Woody Allen here I come.

PS: And I still think Thou rock, God. Nevermind what some people say about Thee.

25 Responses to “Flirting With The Non Believer”

  1. Jeng Miund, yes I do agree with you…
    There is no point flirting with something when you already choose never to act on it.
    It is so unnecessary, so unimportant
    Thank you for reminding me about it :)

  2. Geez, I just talked about this whole faith thingie last night with a friend!!!
    And yet somehow today you post something related to it? What a coincidence!
    Well I can’t comment on the book, I have no idea what it’s all about…

    But speaking of this…

    “There is absolutely a God, and He is indeed great. The thing is we don’t need anybody telling us HOW to worship Him.”

    This is exactly what I have in mind too. And HE rocks indeed, in whatever way I worship him.

  3. Ah, ada yang mencari-Mu di Mecca dan Medina
    Kulihat rumah-Mu di setiap sudut dunia

    Ayat-Mu bertebaran dimana-mana Ya Allah
    You may called it God, Allah, Brahman, Jehovah, Widhi, Satnaam, Ahura Mazda, Adi Buddha, Jinna, whatever…. It does not matter.

    Agamamu apa? Lho emang agama itu apa? Tuhan sendiri agamanya apa? :-D

  4. hahahaha… makanya aku males kalo baca buku ato yg terlalu berat mba. Bukannya terhibur malah jd bingung, kebanyakan mikir, terus ntar jd ikutan stress kaya yg bikin lg. hihihihi… Mba miund Pernh baca wen bad things happen 2 gud people ga? bagus sih, tp di bbrp bagian dia kaya blg kalo tyt Tuhan tuh couldn’t do anything to help us, jd males bacanya. hehe…

  5. I bought eat pray love 2 weeks ago. Sita told me the book is great. Sampai hari ini cuma tahan 60 halaman,dengan harapan bakal ada cerita yang valuable buat gw di halaman selanjutnya ternyata sampai halaman 60 belum ada apa-apa selain keluh kesah tidak berujung.

    o well, mestinya gw beli harry potter aja, walaupun udah nggak se-seru 1-4, still must have book. huehehehehe.

  6. lita: i have been reminded, and whose work was it? God’s ;)

    Teppy: indeed. again, faith is not to be questioned because we will never be able to comprehend God and His ways.

    odiboni: that’s a good point. thought provoking as well :D

    kebobunting: sebenernya bukunya gak berat sih. bahasanya mudah dicerna, tapi substance-nya yang terlalu berat ternyata. orang-orang di barat sana emang beda pola pikirnya dengan kita dan kadang kita perlu tau apa yang ada di kepala mereka karena mereka claim bahwa mereka punya alasan untuk segala hal. itu aja sih yang bikin saya tertarik untuk membaca. buku yang kamu sebutin itu saya belom pernah baca, karena judulnya gak ‘mancing emosi’ hihihihihi :D

  7. Experiencing God is like watching a concert. Unless you’re there, it’s hard to imagine how great the concert was no matter how many people told you how wonderful it was.

    It’s nearly impossible to see God (even though some people did see him as “somebody who comes in full light and holiness during their sleep”). Hence the word experience.

  8. duh teteh, “main-main dengan api” itu emang menarik, tapi ati-ati kebakar,
    mendingan itu buku abis ditaro di freezer terus dibuang jauh-jauh deh,
    soalnya kalo ditaro di freezer masih ada kemungkinan buat teteh ngeliat terus ngebaca buku itu lagi pas teteh lagi ngambil makanan di freezer…

    kalo semua hal tentang “faith” mau dibuat masuk akal bisa kok,
    kan banyak tuh penelitian-penelitiannya…

  9. For me, English book is only for thesis or teaching material. Not for fun. So what I’m g0ing to do n0w, is just h0pe for that b0ok t0 be translated into Bahasa. Coz from the way you write about it, it seems interesting.

  10. Wentjeuh: Eat Pray Love itu isinya emang KELUH semua. ngehe banget. i hated it. masa menangani masalah pribadi aja mesti KELILING DUNIA dulu. bullshit.

    dlew: and how’s the concert to you? good, i hope ;)

    annis: untuk membuang buku itu jauh-jauh adalah hal yang bodoh, karena dengan begitu tandanya saya cuma mau baca hal-hal yang saya setujui saja. tujuannya masukin ke freezer (atau mungkin gak se-literal itu) adalah, saya akan menunggu saat yang tepat di mana saya siap membaca lagi tanpa merasa terganggu. that’s the whole point of this rambling.

    NdutYKe: translated into Bahasa Indonesia you mean? sorry, it’s my pet peeve whenever people say ‘I speak BAHASA’. In english it’s equivalent to ‘i speak LANGUAGE’. what language, then?

  11. hekekek… iya siih… but again, coming from a believer, the Creator is almighty.. it is also Her (or Him) who creates the non-believers. So maybe He (or She) just leads ways to you so that you see something from an angle that you have never seen before. There is no such thing as a coincidence you see… kali lhoooo.. heheheheh :D

  12. as i get older, i question more of faith and God. i know i’m not supposed to because the more i think about it, the more i think of being a free-thinker. but in my defense, it’s just natural for me as a human being to ask so many questions and wonder how does it work. and i know it’s beyond people’s knowledge to clearly explain about God and the universe and we should just accept it for what it is. it is faith after all, you just have to believe it.
    speaking of eat, pray and love, i thought the book is gonna be good. i wanted to borrow it from the library but none are available in the library.

  13. nadia febina: very valid. i think your opinion is by far the closest to clearing the air. thanks! :D

  14. wow..this theme seems so “heavy”, but i agree with nadia febina. and also, whatever books or writings that we read should make us wiser than before..so, just takes anything that good (in your opinion of course) from that book..

  15. DwD: you know, now that i think about it, it’s not a wrong thing either to be a free thinker. as nadia said, from a believer’s point of view, free thinkers are created by the Almighty as well. there must be a purpose for their being on earth co-existing with believer, no? and that purpose, is one thing incomprehensible by human beings, perhaps. btw, yeah do read eat pray love and lemme know what you think. to me it’s serious crap. we’ll talk about it in my english blog. HAHAHKAHKAKA :D

    saesa: it seems, but it’s really not that heavy. i haven’t finished the book yet! :D and yes, books are just reading materials and taking the good instead of the bad (on my standards) is my best bet for this one. ;)

  16. eh, emang eat pray love kenapa ya? kayaknya dipuja2 banget tu buku sama si cici…? gw udah dipaksa baca itu berkali2… .

  17. reney: lo baca aja ney, gue sih ga suka. udah bikin review pula di blog inggris gue. HAHAHAHAH :D

  18. masa sih? menurut gue eat pray love gak whiner sih. yang perjalanan dia di itali emang rada bete, tapi gue masih ketawa. dan gue gak tahu teknik nulisnya dia kayak apa, tapi kalo itu gak jauh-jauh dari pengalaman divorcenya, menurut gue emang pas banget. dan sisanya adalah cerita lucu perjalanan dia ke itali, india dan indonesia.

    tapi emang tergantung orang ya. menurut gue eat pray love sih keren banget. mungkin juga karena pas baca lagi ngalamin masalah yang sama :D jadi berasa senasib, cuma bedanya saya jalan-jalan di metro, sogo dan debenhams aja. 3 dept store toh? lumayan, walopun belum 3 negara :)

  19. well, thx teh for the review?! hehehe i used to bought that book, but i still have a little doubt with it. But now, i am going to buy that books.. thx anyway…

  20. ragilmungil: wah, mungkin gue terlalu negatif ya menanggapinya. abis menurut gue, cewek harusnya lebih kuat ngadepin masalah daripada cuma lari jalan2 untuk menjernihkan pikiran. petualangannya asik sih, dan kalo dimasukin jadi travel journal mah okelah. cuma kalo sampe jadi ‘bible’ orang, menurut gue rada berlebihan ya. soalnya di Oprah show banyak banget yang bilang buku itu mengubah hidup mereka. and how it did that is never comprehensible to me. hihihihihi!

    vincent: which book are you talking about here?

  21. bejo the horrible says:

    well, wthat’s why they call it ‘faith’

    I remember one of my highschool teacher (halo pak Michael !!) said ‘if you don’t have strong faith, don’t read those books !’. And this was about 15 years ago.
    So, these books have been around for awhile..questioning the things that we believe.

    I now understand why he said that..
    I also understand why that other guy said :’ Religion is the Opiate for the masses’

    In a way, I’m just like you, I believe in God, but I don’t want anybody telling me how to pray etc. Also, religion is a spiritual matter, not political etc.
    So, there might be things that I agree in that book.

    For me, religion is only a way, not the destination. Sadly, most people only care about telling others about the right way.

    So, if at the end you’ve became a freethinker because of this book, so what ? (probably you will burn in hell for all eternity :) )
    But, it might be interesting to know how other thinks about religion, but you don’t need to agree.Try to be non-emotional reader lah …seperti lagi baca petunjuk minum obat

  22. bejo the horrible: well isn’t that what’s this musing is all about? i thought i was strong enough and turned out that i feel i’m not ready (to be burnt in hell LOL), hence the freezing of the book. people take everything differently and i do tend to be emotional when reading, even comic books. and no i don’t want to even contemplate being a non-emotional reader because it’s just not fun! :D let’s just all stick to woody allen. that’s the kind of emotion i like :D

  23. wah kalo sampe bible gue juga ngerasa itu berlebihan. gue cuma ngerasa itu buku yang enak dibaca dan perlu *sedap!*

  24. [...] think a lot after reading jeng Miund’s post…She reminded me that there’s no point flirting on something when you already decide never to [...]

  25. luv' deby says:

    teh miund,
    sorry its too late to reply.. tpi nih judul menarik sekali.. :)

    God create us to worship, most people knew as a religion but the truth that all He wants from us is a RELATIONSHIP with Him.
    To know Him..
    And God always hav a scenario for it.. hmm..
    For u, by reading that book.. Maybe??
    Nothin happen by coincident.. ;)
    [eh bner ga yah bhs inggrisnya? ngikutin kya yg di kungfu panda tu teh.. :p ]

    Coz our life has an ending, and our destination depend on what we do now, what we choose now. Soon or later.. we will meet Him. Cannot be deny.

    Our life, driven by eternity.
    Decision is in our hand. :)

    God luv ya..

Leave a Reply